Biocontrol Strategies for Managing Seed Borne Pathogens in Mungbean (Vigna radiata L.): Efficacy and Potential

Author:

Sandhya N. Sawant1*, Sanjay Kolase2, Dhanashree Sarnobat3, S.B. Latke and A.V. Suryawanshi5

Journal Name: Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(10): 42-47, 2024

Address:

1M.Sc. Student, Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology MPKV Rahuri (Maharashtra), India.

2Associate Professor, Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology, MPKV Rahuri (Maharashtra), India.

3Assistant Professor, Department of Plant Pathology and Microbiology MPKV Rahuri (Maharashtra), India.

4Scientist (Plant Pathology), Pulse Improvement Project MPKV Rahuri (Maharashtra), India.

5Assistant Seed Research Officer (Seed Pathology), MPKV Rahuri (Maharashtra), India.

(Corresponding author: Sandhya N. Sawant*)

DOI: -

PDF Download PDF

Abstract

During present investigation it is observed that Biopriming a new technique that integrates biological (inoculation of seed with beneficial organism to protect seed) and physiological aspects of disease control used as an alternative method for controlling many seed and soil borne pathogens. It is an ecological approach in which selected fungal antagonists used against soil and seed borne pathogens. Biological seed treatments provide an alternative to chemical control with additional benefits of induced diseases resistance, ecofriendly nature and sustainable disease management. Mungbean (Vigna radiata) is susceptible to seed-borne pathogens, causing significant yield losses. Biopriming, a non-chemical seed treatment, was evaluated for its efficacy in managing seed-borne pathogens. Trichoderma viride, Trichoderma harzianum, Pseudomonas fluorescens and Bacillus subtilis are different bio control agents frequently used for biopriming treatment in present investigation.  Also it shows reduction in disease incidence, increase seed germination and seedling vigour.

Keywords

Biopriming, Mungbean, Seed-borne pathogens, Trichoderma harzianum, Pseudomonas fluorescens, Bacillus subtilis.

Introduction

Green gram (Vigna radiata L.) is predominantly self- fertilizing and its chromosome number is 2n=22 in family Fabaceae. It is most important pulse crop native of India. Mungbean (Vigna radiata L.) is predominantly self-fertilizing and its chromosome number is 2n-22 in the family Fabaceae. It is important pulse crop native of India. Mungbean is one of the most ancient crops among cultivated plants. It contains 26% protein, 51% carbohydrate, 10% moisture, 4% minerals, and 3% vitamins. It is also rich in Ca, Fe, K and is an excellent source of vitamins such as thiamine, niacin, and vitamin A. Although systematic efforts have been made to upgrade pulses production in order to meet the minimum dietary requirements such efforts are quite inadequate due to various constraints like poor cultivation practices, availability of quality seeds of improved cultivar is considered crucial for realizing productivity and adoption of cultivars in different agro-climatic conditions. 

Poor germination and poor seedling vigour are due to contamination of seeds which results in an unhealthy plant. Field pathogens that are associated with seeds cause depletion in seed quality, affect the viability and decrease germination percentage Kantha and Vaidehi (1980). A large number of fungi were found to be associated with the mung bean seeds. Alternaria sp., Fusarium sp, Aspergillus flavus, A. niger and Macrophomina sp. were found in germinating seed and seedling of mung bean Pradhan (2017). Mungbean is produced primarily for its protein content. 

Seed borne mycoflora associated with mung bean reported recently include Aspergillus sp, Alternaria sp, Fusarium sp, Macrophomina sp., Penicillium sp., Rhizopus sp. These fungi reduce the germination percentage, viability and vigour of seeds. Because of seed borne infections, there is a reduction in production and incapable to satisfy the requirements for mungbean seeds.   Some control measures may be useful for increasing the supply to meet the demand. Seed borne mycoflora are more easily managed as compared to air-borne and soil-borne mycoflora. Seed priming is a quality enhancement technique for rapid uniform germination of seeds and optimum plant stand in the field. This technique is often used as a seed invigoration treatment for improving germination and vigour in low vigour lots. Hence, it appears to reverse the detrimental effects of seed deterioration (Srinivasan et al., 2009).

Biopriming is a new technique of that integrates biological (inoculation of seed with beneficial organism to protect seed) and physiological aspects of disease control. It is recently used as an alternative method for controlling many seed and soil borne pathogens. It is an ecological approach using selected fungal antagonists against soil and seed borne pathogens. Biological seed treatments provide an alternative to chemical control with additional benefits of induced diseases resistance, ecofriendly nature and sustainable disease management. Trichoderma viride, Trichoderma harzianum, Pseudomonas fluorescens and Bacillis subtilis are different bio control agents frequently used for biopriming treatment. Several researchers have investigated the use of beneficial micro-organisms in the priming medium to control disease proliferation during priming itself (Warren and Bennet 2000). The main causes for poor yield in mungbean are fungal, viral and bacterial diseases. The amount of yield loss depends on the intensity of the disease and environmental conditions. Several researchers have investigated the use of beneficial micro-organism in the priming medium to control diseases proliferation during priming itself (Waren and Bennet 2000). Trichoderma viride, Trichoderma harzianum, Pseudomonas fluorescens and Bacillis subtilis.

Material & Methods

Present investigation were carried out to study the effect of biopriming on mungbean in the PGI glasshouse M.P.K.V., Rahuri. The experimental seed crop was raised during kharif 2022-2023 in glasshouse conditions. Seeds of mungbean variety phule chetak was selected. The seeds were inoculated by dipping the seed in concentrated suspension of spores/active hyphae of important seed mycoflora of mungbean for 12 hours and then seeds were dried under shade for 12 hours. The biopriming of bioagents to the artificially inoculated seeds of mungbean was given in plastic vessels. Talc based formulations of the bioagents were weighted on weighing balance as per the dose and mixed with water. Then seeds were soaked in the volume of respective concentration in each of the biopriming agents for 8 hours. After soaking the seeds were removed from the solutions and dried in shade up to original moisture content (8-10%)  The inoculated and untreated seeds were served as control (Meena et al., 2016). A portion of seeds of each bio-priming treatments was used for pot culture.

The study of percent disease incidence was recorded applying 0-9 grade disease rating scale (Mayee and Datar 1986). The Incidence was calculated by using following formula.

The root and shoot length (cm) of randomly selected seedlings from each treatment were measured with the help of measuring scale and seedling vigour index was computed by using formula given by Abdul Baki and Anderson (1973)

Biopriming agents and their Duration of soaking:


Sr. No.

Treatment

Hour of soaking

1.

Trichoderma viride @10g/kg seed

08

2.

Trichoderma harzianum @10g/kg seed

08

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens @10g/kg seed

08

4.

T. viride + P. fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed

08

5.

T. harzianum + P. fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed

08

6.

Bacillus subtilis @ 10 g each/kg seed

08

7.

Control

-


Results & Discussion

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Fusarium oxysporum, seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of mungbean (phule chetak) are presented in Table 1. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Fusarium oxysporum, seed germination and seedling vigour index. The bioprimed seeds with Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective followed by T. viride+P.  fluorescens. The results of present are in agreement with Mukhopadhyaay (1989); Kumar and Dube (1992); Mahamune and Kakde (2011).

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Aspergillus niger, seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of mungbean (phule chetak) are presented in Table 2. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Aspergillus niger, seed germination and seedling vigour index. The seed biopriming with bioagent Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective followed by T. viride + P. fluorescens. The results of present study are in agreement with Pradeep et al. (2000); Koche et al. (2009); Mahamune and Kakde (2011); Gawade et al. (2016).

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Alternaria alternata, seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of mungbean (phule chetak) are presented in Table 3. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Alternaria alternata, seed germination and seedling vigour index. The seed biopriming with bioagent Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective, followed by T. viride + P. fluorescens@ 5 g. The results of present study, on effect of various bioagents on the incidence of seed borne fungi, seed germination and seedling vigour index are in agreement with Koche et al. (2009).

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Penicillium spp. seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of mungbean (phule chetak) are presented in Table 4. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Penicillium spp., seed germination and seedling vigour index. The seed biopriming with bioagent Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective followed by T. viride + P. fluorescens@ 5 g each/kg seed The results of present study, on effect of various bioagents on the incidence of seed borne fungi, seed germination and seedling vigour index are in agreement with Bodhe (2019).

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents  on incidence of seed borne Aspergillus flavus, seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of  mungbean (phule chetak) are presented in Table 5. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Aspergillus flavus, seed germination and seedling vigour index. The seed bioprimng with bioagent Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective followed by T. viride + P. fluorescens@ 5 g each/kg seed The results of present study, on effect of various bioagents on the incidence of seed borne fungi, seed germination and seedling vigour index are in agreement with Pradeep et al. (2000), Koche et al. (2009); Gawade et al. (2016);  Bodhe (2019).

The result in respect of efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Colletotrichum spp, seed germination and seedling vigour index of artificially infected seeds of mungbean (Phule chetak) are presented in Table 6. All treatments were statistically significant over control in respect of incidence of seed borne Colletotrichum spp, seed germination and seedling vigour index. Among tretments, biopriming with Trichoderma harzianum +Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed was found most effective, followed by T. viride+P. fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed. The present results on effect of various bioagents on seed borne mycoflora, seed germination and seedling vigour index in mungbean are in agreement with Shivanna and Shetty (1989).

Table 1: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Fusarium oxysporum (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of mungbean.

Sr. No.

Treatment

Incidence

of F. oxysporum

(%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)

Seed germination (%)


Increase in seed germination over Control (%)

Seedling Vigour Index

(SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)


1.

Trichoderma viride@ 10g/kg seed

21.03

(27.26)

65.75

70.12

(70.00)

16.66

2105.83

23.61

2.

Trichoderma  harzianum@ 10g/kg seed

18.03

(25.08)

70.49

71.12

(71.25)

18.33

2216.35

30.10

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens @10g/kg seed

22.04

(27.95)

63.93

69.12

(67.45)

15.00

2074.78

21.79

4.

Trichoderma viride + Pseudomonas fluorescens @5g/kg seed

17.02

(24.33)

72.13

73.13

(71.86)

21.66

2313.18

35.79

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @5g/kg seed

15.05

(22.77)

75.40

74.11

(75.82)

23.33

2412.01

41.59

6.

Bacillus subtilis

52.08

(46.12)

14.75

67.10

(53.71)

11.66

1908.18

12.03

7.

Control

61.10

(51.33)


60.11

(49.58)


1703.82



S.E.±

0.579


1.172


35.75


CD at 1%

2.435

4.933

150.5

(Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed values)

Table 2: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Aspergillus niger (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of mungbean.

Sr. No.

Treatment

Incidence of A. niger (%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)

Seed germination (%)

Increase in seed germination over Control (%)

Seedling Vigour Index (SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)

1.

Trichoderma viride@ 10 g/kg seed

20.03(26.55)

70.14

78.13(66.01)

20.00

2137.22

32.80

2.

Trichoderma  harzianum @ 10 g/kg seed

18.03(25.08)

73.13

79.13(62.71)

21.53

2152.58

33.75

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens@ 10 g/kg seed

21.04(18.73)

68.66

76.12(60.64)

16.92

1991.31

23.73

4.

Trichoderma viride +Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed

16.04(27.26)

76.11

80.12(63.41)

23.07

2272.11

41.18

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed

15.02(22.74)

77.61

81.14(64.15)

24.61

2429.34

50.95

6.

Bacillus subtilis

55.09(47.85)

17.91

72.10(58.03)

10.76

1800.00

12.03

7.

Control

67.11(54.91)


65.11(53.70)


1602.67



S.E.±

0.612


1.286


34.988


CD at 1%

2.576

5.415

147.29

Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed values)


Table 3: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Alternaria alternata (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of mungbean.

Sr. No.

Treatment

Incidence

of A. alternata

(%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)

Seed germination (%)

Increase in seed germination over Control (%)

Seedling Vigour Index

(SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)


1.

Trichoderma viride@ 10 g/kg seed

21.04

(27.26)

63.15

72.12

(58.02)

18.03

2265.43

30.58

2.

Trichoderm harzianum@ 10 g/kg seed

19.03

(25.83)

66.66

73.11

(58.67)

19.67

2293.82

32.21

3.

Pseudomonas fluoescens@ 10 g/kg seed

22.04

(27.95)

61.40

71.10

(57.39)

16.39

2227.04

28.36

4.

Trichoderma viride +Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g/kg seed

17.03

(24.33)

70.17

74.12 (59.32)

21.31

2453.08

41.39

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g/kg seed

16.03(23.56)

71.92

76.13 (60.64)

24.59

2576.95

48.53

6.

Bacillus subtilis

49.08 (44.40)

14.03

68.11 (55.52)

11.47

2061.76

18.84

7.

Control

58.10

(49.58)


61.10

(51.33)


1749.24



S.E.±

0.557


1.198


37.93


CD at 1%

2.346

5.046

159.7

(Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed values)

Table 4: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Penicillium spp. (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of mungbean.

Sr. No.

Treatment

Incidence

of Penicillium spp.

(%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)


Seed germination (%)


Increase in seed germination over Control (%)


Seedling Vigour Index

(SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)


1.

Trichoderma viride@ 10 g/kg seed

19..03

(25.82)

66.07

68.12

(55.52)

17.24

2243.06

25.90

2.

Trichoderma  harzianum@ 10 g/kg seed

18.02

(25.08)

67.85

72.11

(58.03)

24.13

2281.46

28.05

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 10 g/kg seed

21.04

(27.26)

62.50

67.11

(54.92)

15.51

2171.61

21.88

4.

Trichoderma viride +Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g each/kg seed

17.03

(24.33)

69.64

73.12

(58.68)

25.86

2354.92

32.21

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g each/kg seed

15.03

(22.77)

73.21

74.12

(59.32)

27.58

2425.04

36.11

6.

Bacillus subtilis

49.08

(44.40)

12.50

64.11

(53.11)

10.34

2061.43

15.72

7.

Control

56.09

(48.42)


58.10

(49.58)


1781.62



S.E.±

0.541


1.154


37.10


CD at 1%

2.280

4.857

156.22

(Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed values)

Table 5: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Aspergillus flavus (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of   mungbean.

Sr. No.

Treatment

Incidence

of A. flavus

(%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)

Seed germination (%)


Increase in seed germination over Control (%)

Seedling Vigour Index

(SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)


1.

Trichoderma viride@ 10 g/kg seed

17.03 (24.33)

70.17

73.12  (58.68)

17.74

2160.25

28.04

2.

Trichoderma  harzianum@ 10 g/kg seed

15.03

(22.77)

73.68

74.12

(59.33)

19.35

2226.71

32.51

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens@ 10 g/kg seed

19.01

(25.82)

66.66

71.11

(57.39)

14.51

2092.48

24.02

4.

Trichoderma viride +Pseudomonas fluorescens@ 5g each/kg seed

14.02

(21.95)

75.43

75.12

(59.97)

20.96

2278.79

35.06

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens@ 5g each/kg seed

12.02

(20.26)

78.94

77.12

(61.32)

24.19

2422.36

43.57

6.

Bacillus subtilis

49.08

(44.40)

14.03

69.13

(56.15)

11.29

1903.17

12.80

7.

Control

57.10

(49.00)


62.10

(51.92)


1686.31



S.E.±

0.529


1.213


35.83


CD at 1%

2.230

5.107

150.8

(Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed values

Table 6: Efficacy of seed biopriming with bioagents on incidence of seed borne Colletotrichum spp (Artificially inoculated to seed) and their effect on seed germination and seedling vigour index of mungbean.

Sr.  No.

Treatment

Incidence

of Colletotrichum. spp

(%)

Reduction in incidence over Control (%)

Seed germination (%)

Increase in seed germination over Control (%)

Seedling Vigour Index

(SVI)

Increase in SVI over Control (%)


1.

Trichodera viride@10g/kg seed

20.02

(26.55)

64.21

70.12

(56.76)

18.64

2167.60

21.23

2.

Trichodera harzianum@10g/kg seed

17.03

(24.34)

69.64

71.12

(57.40)

20.33

2218.35

24.07

3.

Pseudomonas fluorescens @10g/kg seed

21.04

(27.26)

62.50

69.15

(56.15)

16.94

2159.25

20.76

4.

Trichoderma viride +Pseudomonas fluorescens

@5g each/kg seed

16.02

(23.56)

71.42

73.12

(58.68)

23.72

2294.82

28.34

5.

Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @5g each/kg seed

15.03

(22.77)

73.21

74.11

(59.32)

25.42

2374.95

32.82

6.

Bacillus subtilis

48.08

(43.43)

14.28

65.11

(53.70)

10.16

1990.31

11.31

7.

Control

56.09

(48.42)


59.10

(50.16)


1787.98



S.E.±

0.537


1.166


36.30



CD at 1%

2.260

4.905

152.82

(Figures in parentheses indicates arc sin transformed val


Conclusion

Among all the seed biopriming treatments, seed biopriming with Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5 g each/kg seed recorded lowest seed mycoflora, increasing seed germination and seedling vigour index in naturally infected seed as well as artificially inoculated seed with all seed borne Fusarium oxysporum, Colletotrichum lindemuthianum, Alternaria alternata, Aspergillus niger, Aspergillus flavus, and Penicillium spp.


Future Scope

The finding of study support the use of novel biopriming agents: Investigate new biocontrol agents, such as plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR), Trichoderma spp., and Bacillus spp., for enhanced efficacy. Develop optimized formulations and delivery methods for biopriming agents, including seed coatings, pellets, or liquid applications. Biopriming’s impact on seed quality and vigor: Study effects on seed germination, emergence, and overall seed health. Investigating biopriming’s efficacy against emerging seed-borne pathogens: Monitor and adapt biopriming strategies to address evolving pathogen population.

Among all the seed biopriming treatment, seed biopriming with Trichoderma harzianum + Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g each/kg seed recorded highest pot emergence and lowest incidence of disease. Among all the seed biopriming treatments, seed biopriming with Trichoderma harzianum Pseudomonas fluorescens @ 5g each/kg seed was found most effective in pot tested characters viz., seed germination, seed emergence, and seedling vigour

References

Abdul-Baki, A. A. and Anderson, J. O. (1973). Vigour determination in soybean seed by multiple criteria. Crop Science, 13, 630-632.

Bodhe, R. S. (2019). Studies on seed borne mycoflora of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L.) M. Sc (Agri). Thesis submitted to MPKV, Rahuri.  pp: 83. 

Gawade, S. B., Zanjare, S. R.,  Suryawanshi, A. V.  and Shelar, V. R. (2016). Efficacy of bioagents and botanicals on seed mycoflora and seed quality in mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wiezek)]. Agriculture Science Digest. 36(1), 30-34.

Kantha and Vaidehi (1980). Effect of culture filtrate on the seed germination and on root and shoot elongation of Phaseolus mungo; Indian Journal of Mycology and Plant Pathology, 6 (2), 212-214

Koche, M. D., Kothikar, R. B. and Anvikar, D. G. (2009). Effect of seed dressing fungicides and bioagents on survival of seed borne fungi and shelf life of soybean. Crop Research, 38 (1/3), 215-218.

Kumar, B. S. and Dubey, H. C. (1992). Seed bacterization with a Pseudomonas fluorescens for enhanced plant growth, yield and disease control. Soil Biol. Biochem, 24(6), 539-542.

Mahamune, S. E. and Kakde, R. B. (2011). Plant pathology incidence of seed borne mycoflora on french bean mutants and its antagonistic activity against Trichoderma harzianum. Recent Research in Science and Technology, 3(5), 62-67. 

Mayee, C. D. and Datar, V. V. (1986). Phytopathometry, Technical Bulletin-I. Marathwada Agricultural University, Parbhani, pp.46.

Meena, B. N., Pandey, R. N. and Ram, D. (2016). Seed bio-priming for management of root rot and blight of mungbean incited by Macrophominaphaseolina (Tassi) goid and Rhizoctonia solani Kuhn. Journal of Pure and Applied Microbiology, 10(2), 1223-1233.

Mukhopadhyaay, A. N. (1989). National seminar and VII workshop of All India Coordinated Research Project on Biological Control, Lucknow.

Pradeep, K., Anuja, Kanad, K. (2000). Biocontrol of seed borne fungal pathogen of pigeon pea. Annals of Plant Protectection Science, 8(1), 30-32. 

Pradhan, S. (2017). Seed health evaluation of mung bean (vigna radiate (L.) Wilezek) grown in agro-climatic zones of chhattisgarh. M.Sc (Ag.) Thesis submitted to Indira Gandhi Krishi Vishwavidyalaya, Raipur (C.G)

Shivanna, M. B. and Shetty, H. S. (1989). Effect of selected biocontrol agents and their combination with fungicides on the mycoflora and quality of seeds in cluster bean. Journal of Biological Control, 3 (2), 113-11.

How to cite this article

Sandhya N. Sawant, Sanjay Kolase, Dhanashree Sarnobat3, S.B. Latke  and A.V. Suryawanshi  (2024). Biocontrol Strategies for Managing Seed Borne Pathogens in Mungbean (Vigna radiata L.): Efficacy and Potential. Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(10): 42-47.