Effect of Potash Application on Gene Expression of Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 in Bt Cotton Hybrid

Author:

Karan H. Parmar1*, H.R. Desai2, B.K. Rajkumar3, N.D. Makwana4 and R.D. Patel5

Journal Name: Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(12): 56-60, 2024

Address:

1M.Sc. (Agri.) Scholar & Jr. Commercial Executive at Cotton Corporation of India Ltd., 

Ministry of Textiles, Govt. of India (Gujarat), India. 

2Major Guide & Associate Research Scientist, Entomology Section, Main Cotton Research Station, 

Navsari Agricultural University, Athwa Farm, Surat (Gujarat), India.

3Assistant Research Scientist, Biotechnology Section, Main Cotton Research Station,

 Navsari Agricultural University, Athwa Farm, Surat (Gujarat), India.

4M.Sc. (Agri.), Department of Entomology, College of Agriculture, 

Junagadh  Agricultural University, Junagadh, (Gujarat), India.

5Assistant Research Scientist, Biotechnology Section, Main Cotton Research Station, 

Navsari Agricultural University, Athwa Farm, Surat (Gujarat), India.

 (Corresponding author: Karan H. Parmar*)

DOI: -

PDF Download PDF

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of different levels of potash (K2O) application on the gene expression of Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 endotoxins in Bt cotton hybrid G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II. A field experiment was conducted at the Main Cotton Research Station, Surat, with 12 treatments, including varying potash levels (0, 40, and 80 kg ha-1), the application of potash mobilizing bacteria (KMB), and foliar sprays of potassium nitrate (KNO3). Potash application significantly influenced the incidence of pink bollworm (PBW), reducing larval populations and flower damage in Bt cotton. Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 expression levels in different plant parts remained above critical thresholds for bollworm management, with higher expressions in treatments with potash application. The study indicates that potash supplementation can enhance bollworm resistance by stabilizing Bt gene expression in cotton hybrids.

Keywords

cotton, potash, bollworm, Cry1Ac and Cry2Ac.

Introduction

Cotton (Gossypium spp.) is a major economic crop with high demand in textile industries worldwide. Bt cotton hybrids expressing Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 have proven to be effective against lepidopteran pests, particularly bollworms. However, various environmental factors, including nutrient availability, influence the efficacy of gene expression. Potassium (K), essential for plant growth and fiber quality, has been shown to affect transgene expression and pest resistance in cotton. This study explores the effect of K2O application on Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 gene expression in Bt cotton hybrid G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II and its impact on bollworm incidence. Cotton is cultivated in varied climate and soil type with mono-cropping approach in Gujarat state due to economic cash crop. As per the soil type, texture and structure, nutrient up-take by plant is differed in rain fed and irrigated cotton. Based on regional suitability balanced fertilizer use is recommended in cotton. Though, Gujarat soil is rich in K content (Bhambhaneeya et al., 2017), the availability may be increased through the use of such organic amendments, foliar applications or potash mobilizing bacteria with supplementation of the K in deficient soils. The balanced use of fertilizers does not affect much the gene expression but the lower dose of nitrogen reduced the expression of gene in Bt cotton. Further, cotton appears to be more sensitive to K deficiencies than other crops, as root system of cotton is less dense than that of other crops (Mithaiwala et al., 1981). It has been found that potash application enhanced protein synthesis resulting in reduced amino acid content of the plant sap, may stabilize expression of genes in transgenic crop and reduced the development and multiplication of insect pests especially of bollworms.

Material & Methods

A split-plot field experiment was conducted using Bt cotton hybrid G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II, with 12 treatments including three K2O application rates (0, 40, and 80 kg ha-1), two levels of KMB, and two foliar spray treatments of KNO3. The study was designed to measure bollworm incidence, larval populations, flower damage, and gene expression levels of Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 across different plant parts at various growth stages. The incidence of bollworms was monitored, and Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 gene expression in different plant tissues were quantified using ELISA.

Experimental Details:

SI

Particulars


Detail

(i)

Location

:

Main Cotton Research Station, NAU, Surat

(ii)

Season and Year

:

Kharif 2018

(iii)

Crop and Variety

:

Cotton, G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II

(iv)

Layout/Design

:

Split Plot Design (SPD)

(v)

Replications

:

3

(vi)

Spacing

:

1.20m × 0.45 m

(vii)

Plot Size

:

Gross: 6.00m × 5.40m

Net: 3.60m × 4.50m

(viii)

Sowing date

Sowing: 27/06/2018

Re-sowing:17/07/2018


Date of Gap filling

:

06/07/2018


Date of 1st Picking

:

28/11/2018


Date of Ring line Picking

:

01/12/2018


Date of 2nd Picking

:

28/12/2018

(ix)

Manures and Fertilizers

:

FYM 10 t ha-1 & NPK:240:40:00 kg ha-1 (Recommended dose of nutrition) common to all the experimental unit

(x)

Cultural operations & Plant protection

:

Interculturing and weeding as and when required and ETL based sprays for sucking pests (as per Table 1)

(xi)

No. of Irrigations

:

One irrigation was given one month after cessation of rain (October)

(xii)

Treatment Details

:



Main Treatment

:

K2O application as Murate of Potash (00:00:60), By Indian Potash Ltd. (Plate I)


First level

:

K0=0 kg ha-1


Second level

:

K40= 40 kg ha-1


Third level

:

K80= 80 kg ha-1


Sub Treatment 1

:

Potash Mobilizing Bacteria (Plate II) 


First level

:

B0=No application of KMB


Second level

:

B1=KMB @2.5 lit ha-1


Sub Treatment 2

:

Foliar sprays of KNO3(13:00:45)


First level

:

NFS=No foliar spray of KNO3


Second level

:

FS=Foliar sprays of KNO3 @3 % (Plate III)

(xiii)

Treatment combinations : 12 (Twelve)


TC1

:

No K2O , No KMB, No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC2

:

No K2O , No KMB,  Foliar sprays of KNO3


TC3

:

No K2O , KMB @2.5 l ha-1 , No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC4

:

No K2O , KMB @2.5 l ha-1,  Foliar sprays of KNO3


TC5

:

K2O @40 kg ha-1, No KMB, No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC6

:

K2O @40 kg ha-1, No KMB,  Foliar sprays of KNO3


TC7

:

K2O @40 kg ha-1, KMB @2.5 l ha-1 , No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC8

:

K2O @40 kg ha-1, KMB@2.5 l ha-1, Foliar sprays of KNO3


TC9

:

K2O @80 kg ha-1 , No KMB, No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC10

:

K2O @80 kg ha-1, No KMB,  Foliar sprays of KNO3


TC11

:

K2O @80 kg ha-1 , KMB @2.5 l ha-1, No foliar sprays of KNO3


TC12

:

K2O @80 kg ha-1 , KMB @2.5 l ha-1,  Foliar sprays of KNO3

(xiv)

Application of treatments:


The main and sub-treatment-1 were applied as basal application 15 days after germination of the crop in respective treatments. The sub-treatment-1 was prepared by thoroughly mixing the liquid potash Mobilizer after proper shaking in the compost and mixed well @2.5 lit 20 kg-1 of compost (Plate IV) and applied near the root zone at 30 DAS (Plate V). Whereas sub-treatment-2 was applied at squaring (60 DAS), flowering (75 DAS) and boll development (90 DAS) stages of the crop (Plate VI).




Table 1: Incidence of pink bollworm larvae (big) on G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II during 2018-19.

Factors

Number of pink bollworm larvae (big)/ 10 green bolls recorded at 15 days interval

90 DAS

105 DAS

120 DAS

135 DAS

Pooled

OV

TV

OV

TV

OV

TV

OV

TV

OV

TV

A. Main Treatment (Potash Fertilizer) K

K0

1.16

1.27

1.50

1.40

1.33

1.34

1.25

1.30

1.31

1.32

K40

0.91

1.15

1.41

1.37

1.08

1.24

1.16

1.25

1.14

1.25

K80

0.83

1.11

1.16

1.25

1.08

1.22

1.00

1.18

1.02

1.19

GM


1.17


1.34


1.27


1.24


1.26

SEm ±


0.05


0.03


0.07


0.09


0.03

CD (5%)


NS


NS


NS


NS


0.08

CV %


16.17


9.99


20.19


26.94


19.16

B. Sub Treatments

Potash Mobilizng Bacteria (B)

B0

1.05

1.21

1.44

1.38

1.33

1.33

1.38

1.36

1.30

1.32

B1

0.88

1.14

1.27

1.30

1.00

1.20

0.88

1.13

1.01

1.19

GM


1.18


1.34


1.27


1.25


1.26

SEm ±


0.07


0.05


0.05


0.06


0.03

CD (5%)


NS


NS


NS


0.18


0.09

Foliar sprays of Potassium Nitrate (F)

NFS

1.05

1.21

1.38

1.35

1.22

1.29

1.27

1.30

1.23

1.29

FS

0.88

1.14

1.33

1.33

1.11

1.24

1.00

1.18

1.08

1.22

GM


1.17


1.34


1.26


1.24


1.25

SEm ±


0.07


0.05


0.05


0.06


0.03

CD (5%)


NS


NS


NS


NS


NS

Interactions

SEm ±

CD (5%)

SEm ±

CD (5%)

SEm ±

CD (5%)

SEm ±

CD (5%)

SEm ±

CD (5%)

KB

0.12

NS

0.10

NS

0.10

NS

0.11

NS

0.05

NS

KF

0.12

NS

0.10

NS

0.10

NS

0.11

NS

0.05

NS

BF

0.10

NS

0.08

NS

0.08

NS

0.09

NS

0.04

NS

KBF

0.18

NS

0.14

NS

0.14

NS

0.15

NS

0.07

NS

PK









0.06

NS

PB









0.06

NS

PF









0.06

NS

PKBF









0.15

NS

CV%


26.75


18.51


19.99


21.65


21.69

Note: P=Period, TV= Square root + 0.5 whereas, OV= Original Values, NS= Non-Significant, GM= General Mean

Results & Discussion

The application of K2O significantly reduced PBW damage, with the highest potash application (80 kg ha-1) showing the lowest flower and boll damage. Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 expression levels were well above critical thresholds in all treatments but showed increased levels in treatments with potash application. Potassium mobilizing bacteria and KNO3 sprays further enhanced gene expression, though differences between treatments were marginal. In the present study, the pink bollworm infestation and damage was found above ETL on G. Cot. Hy. 8 BG II as the technology of Bt cotton lost its effectiveness against pink bollworm. Similar results were aslo found in potash application populations of pink bollworm to Cry1Ac (Dhurua and Gujar 2011) and Cry2Ab2 (Fabrick et al., 2015; Malthankar and Gujar 2016; Gao et al., 2018) or both the genes (Fabrick et al., 2014).

Gene Expression: The expression of Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 in leaves, squares, and boll rinds was significantly higher in potash-treated plots, particularly at 80 kg/ha. Potash mobilizing bacteria did not have a significant impact on gene expression, while foliar sprays of KNO3 further reduced bollworm incidence.

- Seed Cotton Yield: The highest yield (2692.90 kg/ha) was recorded in plots treated with 80 kg/ha of potash, followed by the 40 kg/ha treatment. KMB application marginally improved yields, but the interaction between treatments was not significant. Bhambhaneeya et al. (2017) studied the soil available nutrient status and their indexing in cotton growing areas of south Gujarat and reported high status of K(>280 kg ha-1 ) both in irrigated and rain fed regions in selected samples.

The findings suggest that potash enhances the expression of Cry genes in Bt cotton, leading to reduced bollworm damage and improved yields. This aligns with previous studies showing the role of potassium in plant resistance and gene expression stability. While KMB application did not significantly impact bollworm incidence, foliar sprays of KNO3 were effective in reducing larval populations, especially of pink bollworm. Application of hormone and micro-nutrient did not affect the population bollworms (Abro et al., 2004). With respect to synthetic and organic source of nutrition, some workers did not find any marked effect on whitefly, jassid, thrips and spotted bollworms (Ahmed et al., 2003) whereas less infestation of all three bollworms and sucking pests was noticed in organic source of nutrition (Kedar et al., 2010).

Table 2: Open bolls and locule damage by pink bollworm at harvest.

Factors

Open bolls damage (%)

Locules damage (%)

OV

TV

OV

TV

A. Main Treatment (Potash Fertilizer) (K)

K0

15.01

22.73

9.93

18.33

K40

12.77

20.83

8.15

16.51

K80

9.01

17.22

5.09

12.93

GM


20.26


15.92

SEm ±


1.02


0.68

CD (5%)


4.02


2.69

CV %


17.50


14.91

B. Sub Treatment

Potash Mobilizing Bacteria

B0

12.20

20.28

7.91

16.14

B1

12.33

20.24

7.54

15.71

GM


20.26


15.93

SEm ±


0.54


0.27

CD (5%)


NS


NS

Foliar sprays of Potassium Nitrate (F)

NFS

12.09

20.06

7.51

15.65

FS

12.43

20.46

7.94

16.20

GM


20.26


15.93

SEm ±


0.54


0.27

CD (5%)


NS


NS

Interactions


SEm ±

CD (5%)

SEm ±

CD (5%)

KB

0.94

NS

0.47

NS

KF

0.94

NS

0.47

NS

BF

0.77

NS

0.39

NS

KBF

1.33

NS

0.67

NS

CV%


11.44


7.35

Note: TV= Transformed mean (Arc sine) whereas, OV= Original Values,

NS= Non- Significant, GM= General Mean

Table 3: Effect of potash application on gene expression of square tissue in Bt cotton hybrid.

Factors

Cry2Ab Square (µg g-1 fresh weight of sample)

75

90

105

120

Pooled

OV

OV

OV

OV

OV

A. Main Treatment (Potash Ferilizer) K

K0

72.91

74.43

69.26

68.92

71.38

K40

74.56

76.22

76.62

71.51

74.56

K80

74.34

76.62

75.62

76.54

76.54

GM

73.94

75.42

73.83

72.32

73.88

SEm ±

2.34

2.73

1.57

2.03

1.09

CD (5%)

NS

NS

NS

NS

3.20

CV %

10.99

12.54

7.41

9.76

10.38

B. Sub Treatment

Potash Mobilizing Bacteria (B)

B0

74.09

75.03

71.64

70.38

72.78

B1

73.58

75.80

76.02

74.27

74.97

GM

73.84

75.42

73.83

72.33

73.88

SEm ±

1.50

1.45

1.38

1.59

0.76

CD (5%)

NS

NS

4.12

NS

2.10

Foliar sprays of Potassium Nitrate (F)

NFS

74.16

74.77

72.98

70.45

73.09

FS

73.72

76.07

74.69

74.20

74.67

GM

73.94

75.42

73.83

72.33

73.88

SEm ±

1.50

1.45

1.38

1.59

0.73

CD (5%)

NS

NS

NS

NS

NS

Interactions

SEm ±

CD(5%)

SEm ±

CD(5%)

SEm ±

CD(5%)

SEm ±

CD(5%)

SEm ±

CD(5%)

KB

2.59

NS

2.52

NS

2.40

NS

3.00

NS

1.26

NS

KF

2.59

NS

2.52

NS

2.40

NS

3.00

NS

1.27

NS

BF

2.12

NS

2.05

NS

1.96

NS

2.44

NS

1.03

NS

KBF

3.67

NS

3.56

NS

3.39

NS

4.24

NS

1.78

NS

PK









2.21

NS

PB









1.48

NS

PF









1.48

NS

PKBF









3.64

NS

CV%

8.61

8.19

7.97

9.35

8.53

Note: OV= Original Values, NS= Non-Significant, GM= General Mean, P= Period

Note: OV= Original Values, NS= Non-Significant, GM= General Mean, P= Period

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that potash application can significantly influence the efficacy of Bt genes in controlling bollworm populations by enhancing Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 expression in Bt cotton. These findings suggest that optimal K2O application can improve Bt cotton's resistance to bollworm pests and should be considered in pest management strategies.

References

Abro, G. H., Syed, T. S. and Unar, M. A. (2004). Effect of application of a plant growth regulator and micronutrient on insect pest infestation and yield components of cotton. Journal of Entomology, 1(1), 12-16.

Ahmed, S., Shahid, N., Zia-Ur, R. and Mohsin, B. (2003). Comparative incidence of insect pest complex on cotton varieties subjected to organic and synthetic fertilizers. Int. J. Agric. Biol5, 236-238.

Bhambhaneeya, S. M., Das, A., Zinzala, V. J. and Tripathi, S. (2017). Soil available nutrients status and their indexing in cotton growing areas of South Gujarat. International Journal of Chemical Studies, 5(6), 1717-1724.

Dhurua, S. and Gujar, G. T. (2011). Field evolved resistance to Bt toxin Cry1Ac in the pink bollworm, Pectinophora gossypiella (Saunders) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae), from India. Pest management Science67(8), 898-903.

Fabrick, J. A., Ponnuraj, J., Singh, A., Tanwar, R. K., Unnithan, G. C., Yelich, A. J. and Tabashnik, B. E. (2014). Alternative splicing and highly variable cadherin transcripts associated with field-evolved resistance of pink bollworm to Bt cotton in India. PloS one9(5), e97900.

Fabrick, J. A., Unnithan, G. C., Yelich, A. J., DeGain, B., Masson, L., Zhang, J. and Tabashnik, B. E. (2015). Multi-toxin resistance enables pink bollworm survival on pyramided Bt cotton. Scientific reports5, 16554.

Gao, M., Wang, X., Yang, Y., Tabashnik, B. E. and Wu, Y. (2018). Epistasis confers resistance to Bt toxin Cry1Ac in the cotton bollworm. Evolutionary applications11(5), 809-819.

Kedar, P. B., Suryawanshi, D. S., Waghmare, P. K. and Waghmode, D. B. (2010). Influence of manure (FYM) on the incidence of sucking pests and bollworms in cotton. International Journal of Plant Protection3(2), 253-256.

Malthankar, P. A., and Gujar, G. T. (2016). Toxicity of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry2Ab and the inheritance of Cry2Ab resistance in the Pinkbollworm, Pectinophora gossypiella (Saunders). Indian Journal of Experimental Biology, 4, pp. 586-596

Mithaiwala, I. K., Mirbahar, M. J., Channa, A. A. and Arain, M. H. (1981). Effect of fertilizers on the yield of long staple cotton variety K-68/9 in Guddu barrage  area [Pakistan]. Pakistan Cottons. Agris Journal, 25, 73-79(2).

How to cite this article

Karan H. Parmar, H.R. Desai, B.K. Rajkumar, N.D. Makwana  and R.D. Patel (2024). Effect of Potash Application on Gene Expression of Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab2 in Bt Cotton Hybrid. Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(12): 56-60.