Efficacy of Pesticides Against Mites and Leaf Roller Pests in Mulberry

Author:

Basanagouda Jekinakatti1*, Doreswamy C.2, Chandrashekar Kallimani3, Shivaray Navi4Manjunath Gowda5 and Umashankar Kumar N.6

Journal Name: Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(3): 74-77, 2024

Address:

1Department of Sericulture, College of Agriculture, GKVK, Bengaluru (Karnataka), India.

2College of Agriculture, Chamarajanagara (Karnataka), India.

3KVK, Chamarajnagara (Karnataka), India.

4AICRP on Cotton, Chamarajanagara (Karnataka), India.

5Department of Sericulture, College of Agriculture, GKVK, Bengaluru (Karnataka), India.

6College of Agriculture, Chamarajanagara (Karnataka), India.

(Corresponding author: Basanagouda Jekinakatti*)

DOI: -

PDF Download PDF

Abstract

Field experiments were conducted at College of Agriculture, Chamarajanagara during 2022-23 to evaluate the efficacy of pesticides viz., Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l, Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l, Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l, Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l and Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l along with water spray and untreated control against mites and mulberry leaf roller. The study revealed that the maximum mortality of mites was observed in Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l (100 %) followed by Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l (81.38 %), Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l (67.78 %), Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l (37.45 %) and Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l (29.80 %) in the decreasing order of their efficacy at 3 DAS. The maximum mortality of leaf roller was observed in Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l (100 %) followed by Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l (99.10 %), Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l (96.41 %), Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l (93.00 %) and Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l (49.36 %) at 7 DAS. Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l and Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l were found effective against both mites (Polyphagotarsonemus latus) and leaf roller (Diaphania pulverulentalis) without any phytotoxic effect on mulberry.

Keywords

 Mulberry, Pesticides, Silkworm, Mites, Leaf roller.

Introduction

Mulberry is a perennial crop which can be cultivated on both rainfed and irrigated land and maintained for more than 15- 20 years. Leaf is the only food for mulberry silkworm (Bombyx mori) due to the presence of morin, β sitosterol and swallowing factors (Narayanaswamy et al., 1996). Mulberry leaf production is decreasing due to the attack of various insect and non-insect pests. Being a perennial and high biomass producing plant with luxuriant growth under irrigated condition of recommended package of practices often leading to the breeding and multiplication of various pests. This condition leads to rapid pest proliferation resulted in qualitative and quantitative loss of mulberry leaf leading to low productivity in sericulture (Rahmathulla et al., 2012). Though the number of pests attacking mulberry crop worldwide is more than 300 insect and non-insect pests have been reported (Srinivasa Gowda, 2004). but, In the recent days mulberry leaf roller (Diaphania pulverulentalis) and mites (Tetranychus sp. and Polyphagotarsonemus latus) have becames more serious and draw more attention in mulberry cultivation. So far, insecticide used for controlling sucking pests in mulberry was Dichlorvos (Murugana, 2022). However, for managing both insect and non- insect pests in field crops new chemicals are available in the market which are quite effective. In order to select the best insecticides including new as well as old one requires assessing their efficiency against pests of mulberry. Keeping this in view, the present study was taken up to find out the field efficacy of pesticides for the management of mites and leaf roller in mulberry

Material & Methods

Field experiments against mites and mulberry leaf roller was conducted at College of Agriculture, Chamarajanagara during 2022-23. Two year old established tree type mulberry of V-1 variety with spacing of 6*6 feet was considered with recommended agronomic practices. The experiment was laid out in a Randomized Block Design (RBD) with seven treatments including water spray and untreated control replicated four times. The experimental treatments included five insecticides viz., Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l, Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l, Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l, Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l and Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l along with water spray and untreated control. Treatments were imposed using knapsack sprayer at 30 days after pruning which was coincided with pest incidence. Observations on leaf roller (Diaphania pulverulentalis) were recorded from five randomly selected plants per plot a day before and 1st, 3rd and 7th days after spraying of the chemicals by visual scoring (counting the number of larvae per plant) method. The population of active stages of mites (Polyphagotarsonemus latus) comprised of nymphs and adults which were recorded a before and 1st, 3rd and 7th days after spraying of the chemicals using three windows of 1 cm² leaf area each from the leaf samples representing the top, middle and bottom canopy by visual scoring under the stereo microscope. Per cent mortality of both pests was calculated by following formula;

Mortality of mites (%) =

 

Results & Discussion

Efficacy of pesticides against Yellow Mite, Polyphagotarsonemus latus. The data on mean number of mites/cm2 and corresponding mortality percentage on 1st, 3rd and 7th day after first spray are presented in Table 1.

There was no significant difference in the pre-spray count observations among all treatments which showed that there was uniform distribution of mites on the plants. The results revealed that all the treatments were significantly found superior over the water spray and control. Among the insecticides, on one day after spray least number of mites (2.65) and maximum per cent mortality (52.99 %) was seen in Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC followed by Orgomite (3.19 & 44.55 %), Wettable Sulphur 80 WP (2.99 & 44.46 %), Era Safeguard (3.72 & 26.72 %) whereas, more number (4.48) and minimum mortality percentage (20.43 %) was observed in Azadirachtin 1 per cent. Three days after spray, the lowest mean number of mites (zero) and maximum mortality percentage (100 %) was recorded in Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC followed by Orgomite (1.09 & 81.38 %), Wettable Sulphur 80 WP (1.70 & 67.78 %), Era Safeguard (3.16 & 37.45 %) whereas, more number (3.96) and minimum mortality percentage (29.80 %) was observed in Azadirachtin 1 per cent. The data pertaining to mean mite population on seventh day after first spray revealed that the treatment of both Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC and Orgomite recorded minimum mite population (zero) and maximum mortality percentage (100 %). The next best treatment was Wettable Sulphur 80 WP (0.84 & 83.32 %) followed by Era Safeguard (2.07 & 58.72 %). The least effective insecticide treatment was Azadirachtin 1 per cent which recorded maximum number of mites (3.91) and least mortality percentage (30.70 %).

The results obtained with respect to Chlorfenapyr are in accordance with the findings of Sarkar et al. (2013) (Chlorfenapyr 10 SC 100 g a.i. ha-1) who reported 89.32 % reduction after 3rd day of application in chilli. Chlorfenapyr is an acaricidal pyrrole, and the primary mode of action is to affect oxidative phosphorylation in the mitochondria, which results in the death of the cell through inhibition of ATP synthesis and eventual death of the pest (Arthur 2009; McLeod et al. 2002). The mechanism of action of Chlorfenapyr differs from that of conventional neurotoxins, and mortality of the pest as a result of exposure to Chlorfenapyr is not immediate but takes several days after the initial exposure (Arthur, 2008). Therefore, the results of this study showed that Chlorfenapyr caused rapid mortality of spider mites were unexpected. Leonard (2000) found that Chlorfenapyr was primarily active through ingestion with considerable contact activity indicating that active life stages of spider mites can therefore acquire the lethal concentrations through both feeding and contact with the acaricide material as they move and forage on the plant.

Efficacy of Pesticides against mulberry leaf roller (Diaphania pulverulentalis). One day after spraying the insecticides, all the treatments were remained significantly superior over water spray and untreated control. Least number of leaf roller per plant (3.54) and the maximum mortality (43.34 %) was noticed in the treatment where Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC was sprayed followed by Era Safeguard (3.82 & 35.91 %), Orgomite (3.96 & 34.50 %), Azadirachtin 1 % (4.25 & 29.89 %) whereas, more number (5.00) and minimum mortality percentage (17.90 %) was observed in Wettable Sulphur 80 WP. Three days after spray, the lowest mean number of mites (0.31) and maximum mortality percentage (94.88 %) was recorded in Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC followed by Era Safeguard (0.31 & 93.94 %), Orgomite 80 WP (0.50 & 92.17 %), Azadirachtin 1 % (0.63 & 90.01 %) whereas, more number (4.63) and minimum mortality percentage (23.86 %) was observed in Wettable Sulphur 80 WP. On seventh day after spray, the least number of leaf roller (zero) and maximum mortality (100 %) of leaf roller was noticed in the treatment Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC and the next best treatment was Era Safeguard (0.05 & 99.10 %), Orgomite 80 WP (0.25 & 96.41 %), Azadirachtin 1 % (0.45 & 93.00 %). Higher number of leaf roller (3.05) and minimum mortality percentage (49.36 %) was observed in Wettable Sulphur 80 WP (Table 2). Similar observation has been reported in mulberry by Zhao et al. (2017) who studied the toxicity of Chlorfenapyr to different developmental stages of B. odoriphaga and reported that the Chlorfenapyr caused 50 per cent mortality of 1st, 2nd and 3rd instar B. odoriphaga larvae after 72 h at concentrations of 3.94, 4.12 and 10.11 mg (a.i.) L-1, respectively. This consistency is explained by the fact that Chlorfenapyr has a site of action outside the insect nervous system. Instead, Chlorfenapyr disrupts the respiratory chain and proto gradients by uncoupling oxidative phosphorylation in mitochondria (Black et al., 1994). Similarly, Kumar et al. (2019) recorded the leaf roller mortality rate of 82.51, 83.00, 81.66, 82.34, 81.36, 78.46, 79.57 and 77.37 per cent in Chlorfenapyr, Emamectin benzoate, Azadirachtin, Fipronil, Dichlorvos, Novaluron, Lambda- cyhalothrin and Profenofos at 9 days after treatment, respectively.




Table 1: Efficacy of pesticides against mites, P. latus infesting mulberry.


Treatment details

Number of mites/cm2 leaf area

Mortality (%)

1 DBS

1 DAS

3 DAS

7 DAS

Mean

1 DAS

3 DAS

7 DAS

Mean

T1: Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l

5.65

(2.48)

2.65

(1.78)

0.00

(0.71)

0.00

(0.71)

0.88

52.99

(46.72)

100.00

(90.00)

100.00

(90.00)

84.33

T2: Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l

5.45

(2.44)

2.99

(1.87)

1.70

(1.48)

0.84

(1.16)

1.84

44.46

(41.82)

67.78

(55.45)

83.32

(66.13)

65.19

T3: Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l

5.73

(2.49)

3.19

(1.92)

1.09

(1.26)

0.00

(0.71)

1.43

44.55

(41.87)

81.38

(64.60)

100.00

(90.00)

75.31

T4: Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l

5.08

(2.36)

3.72

(2.05)

3.16

(1.91)

2.07

(1.60)

2.98

26.72

(31.11)

37.45

(37.73)

58.72

(50.03)

40.96

T5: Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l

5.63

(2.47)

4.48

(2.23)

3.96

(2.11)

3.91

(2.10)

4.12

20.43

(26.86)

29.80

(33.08)

30.70

(33.63)

26.98

T6: Water spray

5.35

(2.42)

5.32

(2.41)

5.28

(2.40)

5.24

(2.40)

5.28

0.55

(4.25)

1.28

(6.50)

2.10

(8.32)

1.31

T7: Untreated control

5.26

(2.40)

5.21

(2.39)

5.17

(2.38)

5.13

(2.37)

5.17

0.93

(5.52)

1.67

(7.42)

2.41

(8.93)

1.67

F-test

NS

**

**

**

-

**

**

**

-

S. Em±

-

0.03

0.03

0.02

-

0.69

1.03

0.92

-

CD @ 5%

-

0.09

0.08

0.069

-

2.05

3.05

2.74

-

Figures in the parenthesis are transformed value; ** Significant at 1 %, NS- Non significant; DAS - Days after spraying; DBS- Days before spraying.

Table 2: Efficacy of insecticides against mulberry leaf roller, D. pulverulentalis.


Treatment details

Number of leaf roller/plant

Mortality (%)

1 DBS

1 DAS

3 DAS

7 DAS

Mean

1 DAS

3 DAS

7 DAS

Mean

T1: Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l

6.26

(2.60)

3.54

(2.00)

0.31

(0.90)

0.00

(0.71)

1.28

43.34

(41.17)

94.88

(79.43)

100

(90.00)

79.41

T2: Wettable Sulphur 80 WP @ 2 g/l

6.11

(2.57)

5.00

(2.34)

4.63

(2.26)

3.05

(1.88)

4.23

17.90

(25.02)

23.86

(29.23)

49.36

(44.63)

30.37

T3: Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l

6.03

(2.55)

3.96

(2.11)

0.50

(1.00)

0.25

(0.85)

1.57

34.50

(35.96)

92.17

(74.69)

96.41

(82.31)

74.36

T4: Era Safeguard @ 2.5 ml/l

5.96

(2.54)

3.82

(2.08)

0.31

(0.90)

0.05

(0.71)

1.38

35.91

(36.81)

93.94

(77.75)

99.10

(86.25)

76.32

T5: Azadirachtin 1 % @ 2 ml/l

6.05

(2.56)

4.25

(2.17)

0.63

(1.06)

0.45

(0.97)

1.78

29.89

(33.13)

90.01

(72.30)

93.00

(76.65)

70.97

T6: Water spray

5.95

(2.54)

5.58

(2.47)

5.13

(2.37)

4.04

(2.13)

4.92

6.23

(14.44)

13.78

(21.77)

31.45

(34.10)

17.15

T7: Untreated control

5.99

(2.55)

5.76

(2.50)

5.31

(2.41)

4.18

(2.16)

5.08

3.84

(11.28)

11.08

(19.44)

29.48

(32.88)

14.80

F-test

NS

**

**

**

-

**

**

**

-

S.Em±

-

0.06

0.06

0.05

-

0.53

2.93

2.57

-

CD @ 5%

-

0.18

0.16

0.144

-

1.58

8.71

7.65

-

Figures in the parenthesis are transformed value; ** Significant at 1 %, NS- Non significant; DAS - Days after spraying; DBS- Days before spraying

Conclusion

The present findings suggest that spraying of Chlorfenapyr 10 % SC @ 1.5 ml/l was found effective in controlling both mites and leaf roller in mulberry followed by Orgomite @ 2.5 ml/l which helps in the production of good quality and quantity of mulberry leaf.

References

Arthur, F. H. (2009). Efficacy of chlorfenapyr against adult Tribolium castaneum exposed on concrete: effects of exposure interval, concentration and the presence of a food source after exposure. Insect Science, 16, 157- 163.

Arthur. F. H. (2008). Efficacy of chlorfenapyr against adult Tribolium castaneum and Tribolium confusum (Coleoptera: Tenebrionidae) exposed on concrete, vinyl tile and plywood surfaces.  Journal of Stored Products Research, 44, 145-151.

Black, B. C., Hollingworth, R. M., Ahammadsahib. K. I., Kukel, C. D. and Donovan, S. (1994). Insecticidal action and mitochondrial uncoupling activity of AC-303, 630 and related halogenated pyrroles, Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology, 50, 115-128. 

Kumar, T. S. (2019). Population dynamics of leaf roller, Diaphania pulverulentalis (Hampson) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) of mulberry and its sensitivity to insecticides with varied modes of action and their safety to silkworm, Bombyx mori L. Ph. D Thesis, University of Agricultural Sciences, Bengaluru, India. P.58

Leonard, P. K. (2000). Chlorfenapyr, a novel IPM compatible resistance management tool for fruit production. Acta Horticulturae, 525, 257-276.

Mcleod, P., Diaz, F. J. and Johnson, D. T. (2002). Toxicity, persistence and efficacy of spinosad, chlorfenapyr, and thiamethoxam on eggplant when applied against the eggplant flea beetle (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae). Journal of Economic Entomology, 95, 331-335.

Murugana, M. Sabtharishi, S. and Krishnan, R. (2022). Impact of chemicals used for thrips control on silkworm, Bombyx mori L. Karnataka Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 23 (1), 143-145.

Narayanaswamy, K. C., Geethabai, M. and Raguraman, R. (1996). Mite pests of mulberry: a review.  Indian Journal of Sericulture, 35(1), 1-8.

Rahmathulla, V. K., Kishor Kumar, C. M., Angadi, B. S. and Sivaprasad, V. (2012). Association of Climatic Factors on Population Dynamics of Leaf Roller, Diaphania pulverulentalis Hampson (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) in Mulberry Plantations of Sericulture Seed Farm. Psyche: A Journal of Entomology, 1–6.

Sarkar, P. K., Timsina, G. P., Vanlaldiki, H. and Chakraborty, S. (2013). Arylpyrrole acaro-insecticide chlorfenapyr-a tool for managing yellow thrips (Scirtothrips dorsalis Hood) and broad mite (Polyphagotarsonemus latus Banks) of chilli. Journal of Crop and Weed, 9(1), 188-192.

Srinivasa Gowda, R. (2004). Bio-Ecological and integrated management of mulberry leaf roller, Diaphania Pulverulentalis (Hampson) Lepidoptera: Pyralidae. Ph. D Thesis, University of Agricultural Sciences, Bangalore, India. P.87

Zhao, Y., Wang, Q., Wang, Y., Zhang, Z., Wei, Y., Liu, F., Zhou, C. and Mu, W. (2017). Chlorfenapyr, a potent alternative insecticide of phoxim to control Bradysia odoriphaga (Diptera: Sciaridae), Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 65(29), 5908-5915.

How to cite this article

Basanagouda Jekinakatti, Doreswamy C., Chandrashekar Kallimani, Shivaray Navi, Manjunath Gowda and Umashankar Kumar N.  (2024). Efficacy of Pesticides Against Mites and Leaf Roller Pests in Mulberry. Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(3): 74-77.