Exploring efficacy of organic amendments against Rhizoctonia solani f. sp. sasakii, causing banded leaf and sheath blight in maize (Zea mays L.)

Author:

S. N. Banne1*, A. P. Suryawanshi2, S. S. Kadam1 and J. B. Bhalerao1 

Journal Name: Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(5): 38-42, 2024

Address:

1Ph. D. Scholar, Department of Plant Pathology, Vasantrao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani- 431 402 (M.S.), India.

2Ex. Professor (Plant Pathology) and Principal, College of Agriculture, Udgir (M.S.), India.

(Corresponding author: S. N. Banne*)

DOI: -

PDF Download PDF

Abstract

Maize (Zea mays L.) is an important crop widely cultivated as for food, feed and fodder purposes. Among fungal diseases, banded leaf and sheath blight (BLSB) disease caused by Rhizoctonia solani f. sp. sasakii is a major problem in maize cultivation, all over the world. Recently, use of organic amendments to control soil borne diseases is emerging as one of the promising practises as its cost effective, avoids health hazards eco-friendly and an efficient non-chemical method approach to control the pathogens. Therefore, the polybag culture (screen house) studies were undertaken to manage maize BLSB (Rhizoctonia solani f. sp. sasakii) disease, applying soil organic amendments. Of the 12 soil amendments tested, neem seed cake soil application @ 50g/kg potting mixture was found most effective with significantly highest seed germination (87.57 %), least pre-emergence (12.43 %), post-emergence (15.22 %) and average mortality (13.82 %) and thereby resulted significantly with highest reduction in pre-emergence (81.63 %), post-emergence (83.18 %) and average mortality (82.40 %), followed by the soil amendments viz., Castor seed cake, Karanj cake and Groundnut cake.


Keywords

Soil amendments, Rhizoctonia solani, Banded leaf and sheath blight, Polybags culture, Mortality.


Introduction

Maize (Zea mays L.), the world's leading crop is widely cultivated as for food, feed and fodder which originated from Mexico and Central America and is versatile emerging crops with wider adaptability. Globally, maize is known as "Queen of cereals" because of its highest genetic yield potential and is the Third most important cereal crop after rice and wheat. Maize ranks fourth in production and fifth in the area, among major cereals in India (Kaur et al., 2020).

In India, maize is cultivated on an area of 10.10 million hectares with 34.61 million tonnes of production and productivity of 3.40 tonnes during 2022-2023 (Anonymous, 2022). The predominant maize growing states contributing more than 85 per cent of the total maize production in India are: Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Rajasthan, Himachal Pradesh and Gujarat (Anonymous, 2021). In Maharashtra, the area under maize crop was 0.93 million hectares with 1.77 million tonnes of production and productivity of 1.90 tonnes, during 2020-2021 (Anonymous, 2021).

Among a number of fungal, bacterial and viral diseases, banded leaf and sheath blight caused by Rhizoctonia solani f. sp. sasakii Exner (Thanatephorus cucumeris), is one of the most destructive disease, of common prevalence in almost all maize growing pockets of India. Whatever, maize varieties, cultivars, hybrids and composites under cultivation have been found to be prone to BLSB. Organic amendments applied to the soil improves soil conditions and crop productivity, increase water holding capacity and support other beneficial microorganisms, suppressing soilborne pathogens. Due to polyphagous nature maize BLSB disease difficult to manage with chemicals alone and it is also uneconomical. Therefore, present study was undertaken to explore the possibility of soil application of various organic soil amendments on management of maize BLSB disease. 


Material & Methods

A total of 12 organic amendments were evaluated against R. solani f. sp. sasakii, by sick soil method in black polybags (size: 20 x 30 cm.), under screen house conditions. Black coloured polybags filled with autoclaved potting mixture of Soil: Sand (3:1) were inoculated (@ 50 g / kg mixture) with the test pathogen (Rs-3 isolate) mass multiplied (sand: maize medium) culture, watered lightly and incubated in screen house for two weeks, so as to proliferate the pathogen and made the potting mixture sick. After two weeks of incubation, these bags were amended separately with the coarse powdered test amendments (each @ 50 g/kg potting mixture), mixed thoroughly, watered lightly and maintained in screen house. After 72 hrs. of amendments application, surface sterilized (Sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) solution for 1-2 minutes) healthy seeds of maize Hy. Kanchan were sown (10 seeds / bag), watered lightly and maintained in the screen house. The black coloured nursery polybags containing sick soil (without any amendment) and sown with surface sterilized healthy seeds of maize Hy. Kanchan were maintained as untreated control.

Experimental details:

Design            : Completely Randomised Design (CRD)

Replications   : Three

Treatments     : Thirteen

Treatment details:


Tr. No

Treatments

Tr. No

Treatments

T1

Compost

T8

Castor seed cake

T2

Vermicompost

T9

Cotton seed cake

T3

Poultry manure

T10

Karanj cake

T4

Goat manure

T11

Neem seed cake

T5

Sunflower seed cake

T12

Groundnut cake

T6

Safflower seed cake

T13

Control (untreated)

T7

Soybean seed cake

-

          -

Observations on pre-emergence seed rot (PRESR), post-emergence seedling mortality (POESM) were recorded at seven and 30 days after sowing, respectively. Per cent PRESR, POESM and total mortality was calculated by applying the formulae (Kashyap et al., 2019). The data was statistically analysed at 1 per cent C.D. 

              No. of Seeds un-germinated

PRESR (%) =    ------------------------------------- x 100 

              Total no. of Seeds sown        

                No. of emerged seedlings died 

 POESM (%) = ------------------------------------ x 100

                                 Total no. of seedlings                                                                                              

Total mortality (%) = PRESR + POESM

Further, per cent reduction in total mortality with the treatments, over untreated control (sick soil alone) was calculated by formula 

                                       C - T

Disease control =      ------------ x 100 

                                          C

Where, 

C= per cent average mortality (pre- and post-emergence) in treatment polybags.

T = per cent average mortality (pre- and post-emergence) in untreated control polybags.

Results & Discussion

In vitro efficacy of organic amendments against R. solani f. sp. sasakii (Polybag culture)

A total of 12 organic amendments were evaluated as pre-sowing soil application to assess their efficacy against R. solani f. sp. sasakii, by sick soil method, in polybags under screen house conditions. The results obtained on per cent mortality (pre-, post-emergence and average) and reductions, over untreated control are presented in Table 1 and depicted in PLATE I and Fig. 1.

Seed germination. The results (Table 1) revealed that all the test amendments recorded significantly improved seed germination over untreated control and it was ranged from 46.46 to 87.57 per cent, as against 32.30 per cent in untreated control. However, significantly highest seed germination was recorded in Neem cake (87.57 %). These were followed by the amendments viz., Castor seed cake (77.37 %), Karanj cake (74.33 %), Groundnut cake (70.40 %), Safflower seed cake (68.23 %), Sunflower seed cake (67.53 %), both were on par to each other, Cotton seed cake (64.75 %), Soybean seed cake (59.54 %), Vermicompost (55.91 %), Poultry manure (52.77 %) and Compost (48.83 %) whereas, Goat manure was found least effective with comparatively minimum seed germination of 46.46 per cent. 

PLATE I. In vitro efficacy of soil organic amendments against R. solani f. sp. sasakii, causing BLSB of maize (Hy. Kanchan).

Pre-emergence seed rot (PRESR). The results (PLATE I, Table 1 & Fig. 1) revealed that the test organic amendments significantly influenced pre-emergence seed rot (PRESR) which ranged from 12.43 to 50.54 per cent, as against 67.70 per cent in untreated control. However, it was significantly least with Neem seed cake (12.43 %), followed by Castor seed cake (22.63 %), Karanj cake (25.67 %), Groundnut cake (29.60 %), Safflower seed cake (31.77 %), Sunflower seed cake (32.47 %), both were on par to each other and Cotton seed cake (35.25 %). Rest of the amendments caused comparatively maximum PRESR in the range of 40.46 to 50.54 per cent, but it was significantly highest in untreated control (67.70 %).

Table 1: Efficacy of organic amendments against R. solani f. sp. sasakii, causing maize banded leaf and sheath blight (Polybag culture).


Tr. no.

Treatments

Germi-nation (%)

Incidence (%) *

Av. Mor. (%)

Red. (%) over control 

Av. Red.

(%)

PRESR

POESM

PRESR

POESM

T1

Compost

48.83

(44.32)

51.17

(45.67)

55.35

(48.07)

53.26

(46.86)

24.41

(29.60)

38.85

(38.55)

31.63

(34.22)

T2

Vermicompost

55.91

(48.39)

44.09

(41.60)

47.78

(43.72)

45.93

(42.66)

34.87

(36.19)

47.21

(43.40)

41.04

(39.83)

T3

Poultry manure

52.77

(46.58)

47.23

(43.41)

50.18

(45.10)

48.70

(44.25)

30.23

(33.35)

44.56

(41.87)

37.39

(37.69)

T4

Goat manure

46.46

(42.97)

50.54

(45.30)

54.12

(47.36)

52.33

(46.33)

25.34

(30.22)

40.21

(39.35)

32.77

(34.92)

T5

Sunflower seed cake

67.53

(55.26)

32.47

(34.73)

35.23

(36.40)

33.85

(35.57)

52.03

(46.16)

61.08

(51.40)

56.55

(48.76)

T6

Safflower seed cake

68.23

(55.69)

31.77

(34.30)

34.75

(36.12)

33.26

(35.21)

53.07

(46.76)

61.61

(51.71)

57.34

(49.22)

T7

Soybean seed cake

59.54

(50.49)

40.46

(39.50)

44.33

(41.74)

42.39

(40.62)

40.23

(39.36)

51.02

(45.58)

45.62

(42.48)

T8

Castor seed cake

77.37

(61.59)

22.63

(28.40)

25.36

(30.23)

23.99

(29.32)

66.57

(54.67)

71.98

(58.03)

69.27

(56.33)

T9

Cotton seed cake

64.75

(53.57)

35.25

(36.42)

37.12

(37.53)

36.18

(36.97)

47.93

(43.81)

58.99

(50.17)

53.46

(46.98)

T10

Karanj cake

74.33

(59.55)

25.67

(30.44)

28.77

(32.43)

27.22

(31.44)

62.08

(51.99)

68.21

(55.67)

65.14

(53.81)

T11

Neem seed cake

87.57

(69.35)

12.43

(20.64)

15.22

(22.96)

13.82

(21.82)

81.63

(64.62)

83.18

(65.78)

82.40

(65.19)

T12

Groundnut cake

70.40

(57.03)

29.60

(32.96)

32.34

(34.65)

30.97

(33.81)

56.27

(48.60)

64.27

(53.29)

60.27

(50.92)

T13

Control (untreated)

32.30

(34.63)

67.70

(55.36)

90.52

(72.06)

79.11

(62.80)

00.00

(00.00)

00.00

(00.00)

00.00

(00.00)


S.E. +

0.64

0.66

0.64

--

0.61

0.74

--


C.D. (P = 0.01)

1.88

1.95

1.88

--

1.79

2.19

--

            *-Mean of three replications, Figures in parentheses are arcsine transformed values, 

            Av.: Average, Mor.: Concentration, Red.: Reduction, PRESR: Pre emergence seed rot,                 

            POESM: Post Emergence Seedling Mortality.

Fig. 1. In vitro bioefficacy of organic amendments against R. solani f. sp. sasakii (Rs-3 isolate), causing maize banded leaf and sheath blight (Polybag culture).

Post-emergence seedling mortality (POESM). Similar trend as that of pre-emergence mortality was observed in respect of post-emergence seedling mortality (POESM), which ranged from 15.22 to 55.35 per cent, as against 90.52 per cent in untreated control. However, it was significantly least with Neem seed cake (15.22 %), followed by Castor seed cake (25.36 %), Karanj cake (28.77 %), Groundnut cake (32.34 %), Safflower seed cake (34.75 %), Sunflower seed cake (35.23 %), both were on par to each other and Cotton seed cake (37.12 %) Rest of the amendments caused comparatively maximum POESM in the range of 44.33 to 55.35 per cent, but it was significantly highest in untreated control (90.52 %).

Average mortality influenced by the test organic amendments was ranged from 13.82 to 53.26 per cent. However, it was significantly least with Neem seed cake (13.82 %), followed by Castor seed cake (23.99 %), Karanj cake (27.22 %), Groundnut cake (30.97 %), Safflower seed cake (33.26 %), Sunflower seed cake (33.85 %), both were on par with each other and Cotton seed cake (36.18 %). Rest of the test amendments recorded average mortality in the range of 42.39 to 53.26 per cent, but it was significantly highest in untreated control (79.11 %).

Reduction in mortality. All of the organic amendments tested (Table 1 and Fig. 1) were found effective in reducing pre-emergence, post-emergence and total mortality, over untreated control.

The most effective organic amendment found was Neem seed cake, with significantly highest reduction in PRESR (81.63 %), POESM (83.18 %) and their average reduction (82.40 %). This was followed by Castor seed cake (66.57 %, 71.98 % and 69.27 %), Karanj cake (62.08 %, 68.21 % and 65.14 %), Groundnut cake (56.27 %, 64.27 % and 60.27 %), Safflower seed cake (53.07 %, 61.61 % and 57.34 %), Sunflower seed cake (52.03 %, 61.08 % and 56.55 %), both were on par. Rest of the test amendment recorded reductions in PRESR (range: 24.41 to 47.93 %), POESM (range: 38.85 to 58.99 %) and average mortality reduction in the range of 31.63 to 53.46 per cent.

The use of organic amendments is one of the indirect potential approaches of non-chemical means to control soil borne plant pathogens / diseases, which not only reduces the disease incidence, but also increase soil fertility and microbial activity in general and particularly the antagonist’s activity.

In the present study organic amendments viz., Neem seed cake, Castor seed cake and Karanj cake resulted with significantly highest per cent reduction in pre-, post-emergence and total mortality induced by R. solani in maize. These findings are in conformity with those reported earlier by several workers (Meena and Muthusamy, 1999; Kumar et al., 2006; Aiyanathan and Salalrajan, 2008; Senapoty, 2010; Yadav et al., 2013; Deshmukh et al. 2016; Lal et al., 2017; Agale, 2018; Kumar and Kumar, 2018 and Gaikwad, 2020, Navale, 2021).

Conclusion

Organic amendments viz., Neem seed cake and Castor seed cake were found most effective in vitro against R. solani f. sp. sasakii, with significant mycelial growth inhibition as well as significant reduction in mortality (pre- and post-emergence and average), over untreated control, respectively.


Future Scope

Application of organic amendments can be gainfully employed in soil fertility restoration by small-scale farmers, especially neem seed cake. Neem seed cake can reduce the mining of soil nutrients and improve overall crop productivity. Neem seed cake, has a long-term effect of building the organic matter content of soil which helps in improving the soil physical properties and hence the increase in the nutrient status of soils. 

References

Agale, R. C. (2018). Studies on management of soybean dry root rot caused by Rhizoctonia bataticola (Taub.) Butler. Thesis submitted to Vasantarao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani, (M.S.), India. pp. 135.

Aiyanathan, K. A. and Salalrajan (2008). Organic amendments for managements of root rot of fenugreek. Indian Journal of Plant Protection, 36(2), 277-278.

Anonymous, (2021). https://www.indiastatagri.com/ 

Anonymous, (2021). https://www.usda.gov/ 

Anonymous, (2022). https://www.usda.gov/

Deshmukh, M. A., Gade, R.M., Belkar, Y. K. and Koche, M. D.  (2016). Efficacy of bioagents, biofertilizers and soil amendments to manage root rot in greengram. Legume Research, 1, 1-5. 

Gaikwad. P. (2020). Studies on variability of Rhizoctonia bataticola (Taub.) Butler causing dry root rot of chickpea & its management. Thesis submitted to Vasantarao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani, (M.S.), India. pp. 154-155.

Kaur, H. S. K., Hooda, K. S., Gogoi, R., Bagaria, P., Singh, R. P., Mehra, R. and Kumar, A. (2020). Leaf stripping: an alternative strategy to manage banded leaf and sheath blight of maize. Indian Phytopathology, 73, 203-211.

Kashyap, P., S. N. Singh, M. Surya Prakash Reddy and Jhumishree Meher (2019). Cultural and pathogenic variability of Rhizoctonia solani, causing root rot of soybean in Madhya Pradesh. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry, 8(6), 1326-1329.

Kumar, M. and Kumar, A. (2018). Evaluation of efficacy of different organic amendments against Rhizoctonia solani under the screen house conditions. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry, 7(2), 191-194.

Kumar, M. P., Ramaswamy, G. R. and Basavarajappa, M. P. (2006). Efficacy of soil amendments against sheath blight of rice, caused by Rhizoctonia solani Khun. Karnataka Journal of Agricultural Science, 19(2), 422-423. 

Lal, H. C., Kanak Lata, Savita Ekka, Niraj Kumar and Binay Kumar (2017). management of web blight of mungbean using chemicals, bio-agents, soil amendments alone and in combination. Bulletin of Environment, Pharmacology and Life Sciences, 6(2), 112-116. 

Meena, B. and Muthusamy, M. (1999). Effect of organic soil amendments against rice sheath blight. Indian Phytopathology, 52(1), 92-93.

Navale, M. D. (2021). Investigations on dry root rot of safflower caused by Macrophomina phaseolina (Tassi) Goid. Thesis submitted to Vasantarao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani, (M.S.), India. pp. 139.

Senapoty, D. (2010). Efficacy of soil amendments for the management of rice sheath blight Indian Phytopathology, 63(1), 94-95.

Yadav, B. C., Gupta, R. P. and Singh, S. K. (2013). Efficacy of soil amendments on seed germination, web blight intensity and yield of French bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 83(8), 859-61.


How to cite this article

S. N. Banne, A. P. Suryawanshi, S. S. Kadam and J. B. Bhalerao (2024). Exploring efficacy of organic amendments against Rhizoctonia solani f. sp. sasakii, causing banded leaf and sheath blight in maize (Zea mays L.). Biological Forum – An International Journal, 16(5): 38-42.